Temperament & Profit in Beef Cows: A Vet’s Guide 2025
In this article
🐄💼 Temperament & Profit in Beef Cows: A Vet’s Guide 2025
Dr Duncan Houston, BVSc
In 2025, beef producers face tight margins, making every factor—like animal temperament—crucial to herd profitability. While wild, aggressive cows might raise strong calves, growing research shows “ill‑tempered” cattle come with hidden costs: lower fertility, slower growth, higher treatment expenses, and reduced carcass value.
📌 Why Temperament Matters
Temperament—measured via chute score, pen behavior, and exit velocity—reflects how cattle respond to handling and stress. Studies consistently tie excitable behavior to elevated cortisol, lower pregnancy rates, poor weight gain, and less profit :contentReference[oaicite:3]{index=3}.
🌿 University of Florida Study: Reproductive Impact
Over two years, UF researchers scored ~400 cows (Braford, Brahman × British crosses) on behavior and cortisol, then tracked pregnancy over a 90-day breeding season. Higher temperament/cortisol scores → lower pregnancy probability :contentReference[oaicite:4]{index=4}.
Cows classified as calm were significantly more likely to conceive vs excitable peers—highlighting disposition’s role in herd fertility :contentReference[oaicite:5]{index=5}.
📉 Mississippi State & Feedlot Calves Study
MSU data on feeder calves showed excitable calves had:
- Increased health treatments & cost
- Reduced average daily gain & final weight
- Lower net profit per head: $121 for calm vs $80 for most excitable—a 30% drop :contentReference[oaicite:6]{index=6}.
Even after adjusting prices, excitable calves still cost more and returned less.
🎯 Oregon/Hereford–Angus Study: Aggressive vs Calm
A combined UF/OSU study on Hereford × Angus wild-behaving cows showed aggressive cows had lower pregnancy (89% vs 95%) and weaned 35 lb fewer calf per cow—worth ~$56 at $160/hundredweight :contentReference[oaicite:7]{index=7}.
📊 Financial Impact Across Studies
- Excitable calves net $60–$62 less profit per head in feedlot study :contentReference[oaicite:8]{index=8}.
- Ill-tempered beef cows produce excitable offspring, compounding economic loss :contentReference[oaicite:9]{index=9}.
🧬 Is Temperament Heritable?
Yes—heritability estimates range 0.36–0.45, showing meaningful genetic influence. Selecting calmer cattle can improve herd docility and profits over time :contentReference[oaicite:10]{index=10}.
🛠️ Measuring Temperament on Your Ranch
Chute Score (1–5 scale)
- 1: Calm, no movement
- 3: Moderate activity
- 5: Violent, constant struggle
Exit Velocity
Measure time to exit chute; faster = more excitable. Infrared timers provide precision—but stopwatch or staff observations suffice :contentReference[oaicite:11]{index=11}.
Pen Score
Observe behavior in the pen—aggressive charges, fence pacing, pushing—ranks 1 (calm) to 5 (extremely aggressive) :contentReference[oaicite:12]{index=12}.
✅ Management Strategies
- Score and Cull: Remove top 10–20% worst-tempered cattle annually.
- Genetic Strategy: Use docile bulls/heifers and breed for calm disposition.
- Acclimation: Training heifers reduces stress, hastens puberty, though mature cows show limited benefit :contentReference[oaicite:13]{index=13}.
- Low‑stress Handling: Improve pens, minimize sharp noise, train staff—all improve behavior and reduce cortisol.
📈 Economic Outcomes
- Calmer calves: +17 lb weight at weaning → extra ~$27 per head at $160/cwt :contentReference[oaicite:14]{index=14}.
- Feedlot savings: +$60 net per head :contentReference[oaicite:15]{index=15}.
- Cow fertility boost lowers culling and vet bills, raising herd ROI.
📘 Veterinarian’s Role
As Dr Duncan Houston, I help implement these strategies:
- Coordinate temperament scoring and records at working
- Advise on culling strategies tied to profit data
- Recommend genetic lines with docility traits (e.g. docility EPDs)
- Train staff in low-stress handling methods
- Suggest acclimation protocols for breeding-age heifers
🧩 Integrating into Herd Plan
- Score all animals during routine handling
- Identify and cull the worst 10–20%
- Prioritize gentle genetics and calm replacements
- Train heifers, use low-stress handling year-round
- Track performance and adjust annually
📉 Summary: Profit Drivers of Calm Herds
| Good Temperament | Excitable Temperament |
|---|---|
| Higher pregnancy rates | Lower fertility |
| More calf gain & weight | Less daily gain, light calves |
| Better carcass quality | Tougher, dark cutting |
| Lower treatment costs | Frequent illness, vet costs |
| Extra $60–$120 profit per head | $0–$80 profit only |
🐾 AskAVet® Support
Need help implementing scoring systems, choosing genetics, or training staff? Visit AskAVet.com or download the Ask A Vet App for expert guidance and customized herd health planning from veterinary professionals.
© 2025 Dr Duncan Houston, BVSc | Proudly brought to you by Ask A Vet Blog
