Vet Guide to Soaking Hay for Sugar Reduction in Horses 2025 🌾💧🐴
In this article
Vet Guide to Soaking Hay for Sugar Reduction in Horses 2025 🌾💧🐴
By Dr Duncan Houston, BVSc
Managing horses with insulin resistance, Equine Metabolic Syndrome (EMS), or laminitis requires strict dietary control—especially when it comes to sugar. Non-structural carbohydrates (NSCs), including simple sugars and starches, can be harmful for these sensitive horses. One popular management method is soaking hay to reduce its sugar content. But how effective is it really? 🤔
In this 2025 veterinary guide, Dr Duncan Houston explores the latest science on soaking hay, shares optimal soaking times, and explains how to safely feed horses with metabolic concerns. 🌿💧🐎
1. Why Sugar Matters in Equine Diets 🧪
Horses with insulin resistance, EMS, or PPID (Cushing’s disease) cannot process sugars efficiently. High-sugar hay can cause:
- 📈 Spikes in blood insulin levels
- 🔥 Inflammation and metabolic stress
- 🐾 Laminitis (painful hoof inflammation)
- 🧬 Hormonal imbalance
Reducing NSC intake—especially water-soluble carbohydrates (WSCs)—is essential for these horses. Forage remains vital, but it must be low in sugars.
2. What is Soaking Hay? 🌾💧
Soaking hay involves submerging it in water for a period of time to leach out WSCs. This process is simple but can vary in effectiveness depending on:
- 🕒 Soaking duration
- 🌡️ Water temperature
- 📦 Hay type and density
- 💧 Volume of water used
It’s commonly used as a strategy for horses who cannot tolerate even “average” hay carbohydrate levels. 💡
3. Key Study Findings on Soaking Hay 🧪📊
Research conducted by Dr. Annette Longland in Wales analyzed how soaking affects carbohydrate and protein levels in hay. The study tested 9 types of hay, each soaked in cold water (46°F / 7.7°C) for:
- 20 minutes
- 40 minutes
- 3 hours
- 16 hours
📉 Results:
- 🕒 20 minutes = only 5% WSC reduction
- ⏱️ 3 hours = moderate reduction
- 🕰️ 16 hours = 27% reduction
Protein loss was minimal across all time intervals, making long soaking times safe in that respect.
4. Practical Soaking Guidelines for 2025 💧🐎
✅ Setup Tips
- Use a clean muck tub, laundry basket, or hay bag
- Weigh hay before soaking (4–6 lbs typical)
- Submerge fully in 5–6 gallons of fresh water
- Drain and rinse lightly before feeding
⏳ Recommended Soaking Times
| Soaking Time | Effectiveness | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| 20 min | Minimal (5% reduction) | Low-NSC hay or mild cases |
| 60 min | Fair (10–15% reduction) | Moderate risk horses |
| 3–6 hours | Good (~20% reduction) | EMS or IR horses |
| 12–16 hours | Maximum (~27% reduction) | High-risk or laminitic horses |
5. When Soaking Isn’t Enough ⚠️
Even after soaking, some hays may still have too much sugar for sensitive horses. For example:
- Hay starting at 20% NSC may only drop to 15% after soaking
- Goal for insulin-resistant horses is under 10% NSC
Dr Duncan Houston’s advice: “Start with tested, low-NSC hay when possible. Soaking is a backup—not a cure-all.” 🧠
6. How to Test Your Hay for NSC 🧪🌿
To ensure your hay is safe:
- Send samples to an equine forage lab (e.g., Equi-Analytical)
- Request analysis for WSC, ESC, and starch
- Add WSC + starch to get total NSC
Ideal NSC for insulin-resistant horses: ≤10%
7. Health Risks of High-Carb Hay 🩺
Feeding high-sugar hay to sensitive horses can trigger:
- 💥 Laminitis flare-ups
- 🧬 Worsened insulin resistance
- 💤 Lethargy, weight gain, cresty necks
- 🔥 Systemic inflammation
8. Downsides of Soaking Hay 🧽
- 👃 Smell: Can produce sour odor if soaked too long
- 🧫 Bacteria growth: Especially in warm weather
- 💧 Nutrient leaching: Some minerals and vitamins lost with prolonged soaking
- 🧹 Messy: Draining and cleanup can be time-consuming
To minimize issues, always feed soaked hay immediately and clean your soaking tools daily. 🧼
9. Storage & Safety of Soaked Hay 🧊
Do not store soaked hay overnight or re-soak. Always:
- ❄️ Soak in cool areas
- 🧺 Drain hay for 10–15 minutes before feeding
- 🗑️ Discard leftovers not consumed within 1–2 hours
10. Alternatives to Soaking 🚫💧
Low-Sugar Hay Sources:
- 🌾 Timothy, teff, or mature orchard grass
- 🎋 Late-cut hay with thick stems
- 🧪 Lab-tested hay <10% NSC
Forage Replacements:
- 🥕 Low-NSC hay pellets or cubes (soaked)
- 🍀 Chopped forage blends made for EMS horses
Always read labels carefully and check NSC values when possible. 📊
11. Summary Chart: Soaking Hay at a Glance 📋
| Soaking Time | Sugar Reduction | Use For |
|---|---|---|
| 20 mins | ~5% | Basic maintenance |
| 1 hour | ~10–15% | Mild IR |
| 3–6 hours | ~20% | Moderate cases |
| 12–16 hours | ~27% | Severe laminitis/IR |
12. Dr Duncan Houston’s Final Thoughts 💬
Soaking hay is an effective, low-cost strategy to reduce sugar for metabolically sensitive horses—but it’s not a substitute for proper forage selection. Start with the best hay possible, test when you can, and use soaking as a tool to fine-tune your horse’s diet. 🌾💧
Need help designing a custom feeding plan for your horse with EMS or laminitis? Visit AskAVet.com or download the Ask A Vet app 📲 to speak with equine experts and receive tailored nutrition support 24/7.
— Dr Duncan Houston, BVSc
