Skip to content
ASK A VET

Surgical Margin and Tension Line Calculator

Pick the tumour type, or "Unknown" if the sample did not name it, then where it is, and type the diameter for the margin to mark at the sides in mm, the fascial planes to take beneath, and the width and length of the cut. Mast cell tumours, soft tissue sarcomas, injection-site sarcomas, carcinomas, melanomas and benign tumours in dogs and cats. The mouth, toe, eyelid, ear canal, anal sac and mammary gland are regions, each with its own surgery. Then pick the body region for which way the skin tension runs, which way to point the cut, and how to close it: flaps on a named vessel, local flaps, grafts, round-hole patterns, sutures and drains. Lymph nodes, staging, scar re-excision, the limb circumference check, the margin report, shrinkage, rechecks and wound breakdown are covered too. No margin is shown for a lump that has not been sampled. 28 tools for dogs and cats and 29 drawings, with a page each for horses, rabbits and ferrets.

Before you begin: sample the lump first. Measure it with a ruler. Draw the margin on the skin before the first cut, and plan the closure to fit the margin, never the other way round.

Patient

Species and weight

The margins were measured in dogs and cats, who have the full set of tools. Horses, rabbits and ferrets each have a page of their own. The other species have a page that says what is and is not known. Weight in kg is needed for mast cell tumour premedication and suture sizes.

Species
Tool

What do you need?

Pick a tool. Your entries are kept when you switch between them.

Enter

Enter what you have. The result updates as you go.

Result

Result

Updates with every change.

The result will appear here

For veterinarians and veterinary nurses. An aid to planning, not a substitute for clinical judgement. A margin is chosen from a diagnosis, never from the look of a lump. Tension lines differ between patients: test the skin by hand every time.

How this tool works

Surgical margin and tension line guide

Quick answer

For a low or intermediate grade mast cell tumour in a dog, take 20 mm at the sides and one fascial plane deep. Where 20 mm will not close, a margin equal to the widest diameter, never under 10 mm, is the studied alternative. For a soft tissue sarcoma take 20 to 30 mm and one fascial plane, and 50 mm and two planes for grade III. For an injection-site sarcoma in a cat take 50 mm and two fascial planes. Benign lumps need only a narrow rim. Point the long axis of the cut along the skin tension lines, and confirm them with a pinch test on the standing patient.

How to use the calculator

  1. Pick the species. Dogs and cats see every tool. Horses, rabbits and ferrets each see a page written for them.
  2. "Margin for this tumour": pick how it was diagnosed, the tumour type, the grade and where it is, and type the widest diameter in mm or cm. The tumour list holds tumour types only. Pick "Unknown" if the sample did not name it. The region list holds the body regions and the mouth, eyelid, ear canal, anal sac and mammary gland. The result gives the margin at the sides, the depth, and the width of the cut.
  3. "Size of the cut" takes the diameter and the margin and gives the width and length of the ellipse.
  4. "Tension lines by body region" gives the usual direction of the lines, which way to point the cut, and how that region closes. "Finding the tension lines by hand" is the test to do on every patient.
  5. "The deep margin: fascial planes" says what counts as a plane in each region. "Will it close?" lists what to try, in order.
  6. "Reading the margin report" takes the clear margins on the report in mm or cm. Type 0 if tumour reaches the edge.
  7. "Before the first cut" and "Sending the lump to the laboratory" are checklists.
  8. "Lymph node plan", "Staging by tumour" and "When surgery is not enough" plan what goes with the surgery.
  9. "Cutting out a scar" and "Limb circumference check" take typed lengths in mm or cm. "Marked margin against reported margin" takes both in mm or cm.
  10. "Axial pattern flaps", "Local flaps", "Skin grafts", "Closing a round hole", "Removing a pucker", "Suture choice" and "Drains and dead space" cover the closure. "Recheck schedule", "The wound has opened" and "Pain plan for wide surgery" cover what follows.

Margins used

TumourAt the sidesDeep
Dog: mast cell tumour, low or intermediate grade, or not yet graded20 mm, or the widest diameter (never under 10 mm) where 20 mm will not closeOne fascial plane
Dog: mast cell tumour, high grade30 mmOne fascial plane
Dog: soft tissue sarcoma, low grade20 mm under 30 mm across, 30 mm at 30 mm or more. A narrow removal is accepted at or below the elbow or stifleOne fascial plane
Dog: soft tissue sarcoma, intermediate or not graded30 mmOne fascial plane
Dog: soft tissue sarcoma, high grade50 mm. Where that cannot be taken, 30 mm and one plane is the minimumTwo fascial planes
Dog: squamous cell carcinoma, melanoma20 mmOne fascial plane
Dog: haemangiosarcoma20 mm in the skin, 30 mm under the skin or into muscleOne fascial plane
Dog: infiltrative lipoma30 mm, or the muscle compartmentBy CT
Dog: plasmacytoma10 mmOne fascial plane
Dog: mammary gland, any type10 mm under 5 mm across and not fixed. The whole gland with 20 mm of skin at 5 mm or moreJust under the lump, with the fat around it, under 5 mm. Down to the body wall for the whole gland
Dog and cat: benign tumour, hepatoid gland adenoma1 to 2 mmJust under the lump
Dog: lipomaNone. Shell it outNone
Cat: injection-site sarcoma50 mmTwo fascial planes
Cat: other soft tissue sarcoma30 mmOne fascial plane
Cat: mast cell tumour, squamous cell carcinoma10 mmOne fascial plane
Cat: basal cell tumour5 mmJust under the lump
Cat: mammary gland, any typeThe whole chain on that sideDown to the body wall
Dog and cat: unknown type, or gland carcinoma, on the skin20 mmOne fascial plane
Dog: subcutaneous mast cell tumour20 mm, or the widest diameter (never under 10 mm) where 20 mm will not closeOne fascial plane
Dog: liposarcoma30 mmOne fascial plane
Dog: mouth, any malignant or unknown type20 mm of gum and boneFull thickness of the bone
Dog: acanthomatous ameloblastoma10 mm of gum and boneFull thickness of the bone
Cat: mouth, any malignant or unknown type20 mm of gum and boneFull thickness of the bone
Eyelid1 mm for a benign type, or unknown in a dog. 5 mm for a malignant type, or unknown in a catFull thickness of the lid
Toe (carcinoma, melanoma or unknown), ear canal and anal sacRemove the whole toe, canal or sac. No measured margin applies
Scar re-excisionWidth is the first wound plus twice the margin, or twice the margin plus 5 mm if that is not known. Length is the scar plus the margin at each end, or the width times the length-to-width ratio where that is longer
Limb circumferenceOver 15% of the way around: have a second plan. Over 30%: will not close directly. A guide, not a measured rule
Mitotic countMast cell tumour (dog): over 5 in 10 fields is high. Cats: no agreed cut-off. Sarcoma: 9 or more is high
EllipseWidth is the tumour plus both margins. Length is 3 to 4 times the width
Margin report0 mm is incomplete. Under 1 mm is close. An intact fascial layer at the deep edge counts as clean

Safety checks built in

  • No margin is shown for a lump marked "Not sampled". The tool says to sample it first.
  • The diagnosis, the tumour and the region all start at "Not chosen", so nothing is assumed.
  • The margin is never reduced for a difficult site. Where a cut that wide may not close, the tool says so and lists flaps, grafts, open healing and amputation.
  • A benign diagnosis with a fixed, ulcerated or fast-growing lump is flagged.
  • Every length switches between mm and cm, the choice carries to every tool, and a value outside the possible range for that unit is refused.
  • Mast cell tumour premedication appears only when the mast cell box is ticked and a weight is entered.
  • Margins measured in dogs and cats are never applied to another species without saying so. The horse, rabbit and ferret pages give the figures in common use for those species, each marked as not measured.
  • A two-step grade of "High", or a typed mitotic count of 7 or more, overrides the three-step grade for a dog mast cell tumour and gives the 30 mm margin. So does "Not graded" with a fixed, ulcerated, fast-growing or recurrent tumour.
  • Mouth and eyelid tumours get their own wording: gum and bone, or a lid wedge, with no skin ellipse or fascial plane advice.
  • Tumour type and region are picked separately, and both are needed. In the mouth, eyelid, ear canal, anal sac, mammary gland and toe, the region sets the operation and the type names it.
  • A type that cannot arise in the region picked is refused, with the region to pick instead: a mast cell tumour over a mammary gland is a skin tumour of the belly, and a lipoma does not arise in an anal sac.
  • "Unknown" on the skin gives the margin for a malignant tumour, 20 mm and one fascial plane (30 mm if fixed or fast-growing), with advice to biopsy first.
  • Skin grafts show "not ready" until all three bed ticks are on. Suture sizes appear only once a weight is entered.
  • A wound that has opened is never closed again over infection, tension or tumour: those ticks override "early and clean".
  • The pain plan names no doses except the local anaesthetic totals. For a mast cell tumour it removes morphine and pethidine, and for cats it removes the lidocaine drip.
  • A limb cut wider than the limb is refused, and every axial pattern flap page says to check the landmarks against a surgical atlas.

What the evidence says

  • In 23 mast cell tumours marked at 10, 20 and 30 mm, every grade I tumour was fully removed at all three. Of grade II tumours, 75% were fully removed at 10 mm and all of them at 20 mm.
  • In 23 grade I and II mast cell tumours removed with 20 mm and one fascial plane, 91% were completely excised and none recurred over a median of 379 days.
  • With a margin equal to the tumour diameter, 40 of 47 mast cell tumours were removed with clear margins. With the same rule capped at 20 mm, 95 of 100 were completely excised and 3 recurred. Grade and size did not change the result.
  • In 35 dogs with low-grade sarcomas at or below the elbow or stifle removed with narrow margins, 10.8% recurred and none spread.
  • In 91 cats with injection-site sarcomas removed with 50 mm margins, 14% recurred. Median survival was 1,461 days without recurrence and 499 days with it.
  • Skin tension lines were mapped in the dog in 1966 and in beagles in 2003, and cleavage lines in the cat in 1951. The directions given for each region are a guide, and the limb and tail entries rest on surgical practice more than on the map.
  • In 148 dogs with mast cell tumours, median survival was 70 months with a mitotic count of 5 or less and 2 months above 5, whatever the grade. The two-step grade calls a tumour high with 7 or more mitoses in 10 fields: median survival was under 4 months for high grade and over 2 years for low.
  • In 306 dogs with mast cell tumours under the skin, 8% regrew and 4% spread, although 56% had incomplete margins.
  • In 19 dogs with mast cell tumours, the first draining node was not the nearest node in 8.
  • In 19 mast cell tumours, the tumour shrank by 4% and the normal skin around it by 24%, mostly at the moment of cutting. In cadaver skin, shrinkage did not differ by body region or direction, and formalin added none.
  • In cadaver skin, muscle and fascia removed with 20 mm margins, every margin was smaller after removal and after fixation than the one planned. Suturing the skin to the fascia stopped the layers sliding but did not change the shrinkage.
  • Of 70 flaps from the belly on the vessel from the groin, the result was good in 77% of dogs and 79% of cats, with complications in 67% of dogs and 53% of cats, most of them minor.
  • Margins for the other tumours, flap landmarks, the limb circumference bands, suture sizes, drain volumes, recheck intervals and the premedication doses are the ones in common use. Check them against your own protocols.

Common questions

Should I take 20 mm or the proportional margin?

Both are supported. The tool shows 20 mm, as the Skin and Ear Treatment Calculator does, and gives the proportional margin, never under 10 mm, for a site where 20 mm will not close.

What if the margin will not fit?

Plan the closure to fit the margin: a flap, a graft, open healing or amputation. A planned narrow removal with further treatment is a decision to make with the owner before surgery, not on the table.

Are the tension lines the same in every dog?

No. They vary with breed, age and body shape. Use the region guide to plan, and the pinch test on the standing patient to decide.

The report says clean but narrow. Is that enough?

For a low-grade tumour, usually. For a high-grade tumour or an injection-site sarcoma, treat under 1 mm as not fully removed.

Sources

    ASK A VET™ · Surgical Margin and Tension Line Calculator · By Dr Duncan Houston · Talk. Track. Trust.

    Ask A Vet’s vet support lives in the app. See the app

    Dr Duncan Houston
    About the author

    Dr Duncan Houston · BVSc, Veterinarian

    Emergency & critical careGeneral practiceMobile vet careDog behaviour & trainingCat behaviourFounder & CEO

    Dr Duncan Houston is an Australian veterinarian with experience in emergency, general-practice and mobile veterinary care. He is the founder of ASK A VET™. This guide is educational and is not a substitute for hands-on veterinary care.

    Last reviewed